VIA Legal (647) 460-3430 Free Case ReviewFree Case Review
Denied benefits About Naira Guides FAQ

Psychological injuries and the Minor Injury Guideline in Ontario: anxiety, depression and PTSD after a car accident

If your insurer classified your injuries under the Minor Injury Guideline (MIG) and you have had anxiety, low mood, post-traumatic stress symptoms or insomnia since the accident, the classification can be challenged. The SABS definition of a minor injury lists physical injuries and their clinically associated consequences, so an accident-related psychological impairment can fall outside that definition. Symptoms alone may be treated as part of a soft-tissue injury. What can support removal from the MIG is medical evidence: a diagnosis from a qualified professional, medical records documented over time, and a link to the accident.

The MIG is a binding guideline under the SABS that sets out the treatment for minor injuries that an insurer pays for without prior approval, within a $3,500 limit plus any applicable HST. For the basics, see our guides to the Minor Injury Guideline in Ontario, what the $3,500 limit pays for and concussion and the MIG.

Is a psychological injury a minor injury under the SABS?

The Statutory Accident Benefits Schedule (SABS, O. Reg. 34/10) defines a minor injury in section 3(1) as “one or more of a sprain, strain, whiplash associated disorder, contusion, abrasion, laceration or subluxation and includes any clinically associated sequelae to such an injury.”

The injuries specifically listed are physical injuries. Depression, anxiety disorders and post-traumatic stress disorder are not listed. The same section defines “impairment” as “a loss or abnormality of a psychological, physiological or anatomical structure or function”, so a psychological impairment is an impairment within the meaning of the SABS.

Two phrases matter here:

  • “Clinically associated sequelae”. Anxiety while travelling by car, poor sleep or irritability following a neck or back injury may be treated as consequences of that physical injury and may not, on their own, take the person outside the MIG.
  • “Predominantly”. Under section 18(1), the $3,500 limit applies to a person who “sustains an impairment that is predominantly a minor injury.” A person with whiplash and a diagnosed, accident-related psychological impairment may qualify to be removed from the MIG if the evidence shows that their impairment is not predominantly a minor injury.

Is psychological treatment paid from the $3,500 MIG limit?

Psychological services are a medical benefit under section 15(1)(b) of the SABS. While a person remains subject to the MIG, section 18(1) limits “the sum of the medical and rehabilitation benefits” to $3,500 plus any applicable HST, for accidents on or after June 3, 2019.

The Guideline itself (Superintendent’s Guideline No. 01/14) addresses psycho-social issues within its functional restoration approach. At the initial visit, the health practitioner reviews and documents “psycho-social risk factors”, and the Guideline states that this review “does not involve a formal psychological assessment.” Supplementary goods and services, up to $400 in total, may include “advice/education to deal with accident related psycho-social issues”, such as distress or “driving problem/stress”.

These limited supportive services are not the same as a formal psychological assessment or a course of psychotherapy. Where a separate psychological assessment or treatment is needed, an OCF-18 may be required.

The initial review under the MIG may not be enough on its own to establish a psychological impairment. Fees for an insurer examination under section 44 are excluded from the limit (s. 18(5)(a)).

What medical evidence can support removal from the MIG?

Medical evidence that can support removal from the MIG may include the items below. Each can be important, but none is necessarily the only way to establish an impairment.

  1. A diagnosis from a qualified professional. The SABS lists a psychologist among health practitioners for an impairment that “a psychologist is authorized by law to treat”. A physician’s diagnosis, including a family doctor’s, can also be important evidence.
  2. Medical records showing symptoms over time. Symptoms recorded at several visits, with dates, can show that the problem continued and was reported as it developed.
  3. Causation. The medical records should link the psychological impairment to the accident: when the symptoms began, what changed after the accident, and, if there was an earlier psychological history, how the accident affected it.

What did the Tribunal decide in Torgbor?

In Torgbor v. TD General Insurance Company, 2026 CanLII 56654 (ON LAT), released June 5, 2026, the Tribunal removed the claimant from the MIG based on a psychological impairment (paras. 22 to 30). The evidence it relied on included a psychologist’s diagnosis and walk-in clinic records that documented low mood on January 19, 2024 and anxiety and insomnia on August 8, 2024. The Tribunal also considered the impairment’s effects on the claimant’s functioning and found that the accident caused his psychological complaints.

The Tribunal assigned less weight to the report of the insurer’s psychologist, Dr. Cobrin, partly because he used only one psychometric test, designed for native English speakers, and because his original and addendum reports were inconsistent (para. 27).

What should you check before an insurer’s psychological examination?

When the insurer responds to an OCF-18 and believes the MIG applies, their notice may require you to undergo an examination under section 44 (s. 38(10)). The examiner is chosen by the insurer and must be a regulated health professional or a person with expertise in vocational rehabilitation (s. 44(1)). The insurer cannot require a section 44 examination for a benefit payable under the MIG itself (s. 44(3)(a)).

The notice must set out the medical and any other reasons for the examination and the examiner’s name, regulated health profession and any designation indicating specialization (s. 44(5)). If you must attend in person, the insurer must give the notice at least five business days before the examination, unless you and the insurer agree otherwise (s. 44(6)). At the examination you are required to submit to “all reasonable physical, psychological, mental and functional examinations” (s. 44(9)).

Points to check:

  • Does the examiner’s profession and designation fit the question the insurer asked?
  • If English is not your first language, ask the insurer in writing for an interpreter well before the examination. Afterwards, write down which questionnaires you completed and in what language.
  • Within 10 business days after receiving a section 44 report relating to a treatment plan, the insurer must give a copy to you and to the regulated health professional who prepared the plan (s. 38(13)). Compare it with your own medical records.

Missing a properly requested examination may prevent you from applying to the Licence Appeal Tribunal, although the Tribunal may permit an application (s. 55(1)2 and 55(2)). Our article on insurer examinations explains the notice in more detail.

How can a MIG classification be disputed?

Treatment and assessments outside the MIG generally require a Treatment and Assessment Plan (OCF-18). The plan must be completed and signed by a regulated health professional, and the health practitioner’s statement in it can state that “the insured person’s impairment is not predominantly a minor injury” (s. 38(3)(c)). For clinics and psychologists, the diagnosis, when symptoms began and the link to the accident should be clearly documented and supported by relevant medical records.

Within 10 business days after receiving the plan, the insurer must give a notice of what they agree and do not agree to pay for, with the medical and other reasons (s. 38(8)). If the insurer fails to give the required notice, section 38(11) prohibits them from taking the position that the MIG applies and requires payment for the goods and services described in the plan that relate to the period beginning on the 11th business day after receipt and ending when the required notice is given.

Under section 38(5), the insurer may refuse to accept a plan covering a period during which you are entitled to goods or services under the MIG. Section 38(6) makes such a refusal “final and is not subject to review.” Section 38(7) allows a plan for a period other than the MIG treatment period.

When new medical evidence becomes available, for example a later psychological diagnosis, it can be submitted to the insurer to request reconsideration of the MIG classification. If the insurer does not change their position, the insured person may apply to the Licence Appeal Tribunal under section 280(2) of the Insurance Act. Under section 56 of the SABS, the application “shall be commenced within two years after the insurer’s refusal to pay the amount claimed.” See our pages on the LAT and on Accident Benefits denials.

What should you do if the insurer classified you under the MIG?

  1. Keep the insurer’s written notice that the MIG applies and any written refusal of a treatment plan.
  2. Tell your family doctor about every psychological symptom since the accident and when it began, and ask that it be recorded.
  3. Ask your doctor whether a referral to a psychologist or another qualified professional is appropriate.
  4. Ask your treating practitioner whether an OCF-18 for a psychological assessment or treatment outside the MIG is appropriate.
  5. Submit the new medical evidence to the insurer and request reconsideration of the MIG classification.
  6. Attend any properly requested insurer examination and request a copy of the report.
  7. If the insurer does not change their position, consider an application to the Licence Appeal Tribunal, keeping the two-year limitation period in mind.

Naira Velumyan is a Licensed Paralegal and holds a PhD in Psychology, which helps her review psychological reports with particular attention to the tests used and the language of the assessment. VIA Legal does not provide psychological assessments or treatment. We review your case and explain your options in English, Russian, Ukrainian and Armenian. VIA Legal represents clients in Accident Benefits claims, including those under the Minor Injury Guideline (MIG). For cases involving potential catastrophic impairment (CAT), we collaborate with experienced personal injury lawyers.

Classified under the MIG with anxiety, depression or sleep problems after the accident?

Ask us for a free case review

Frequently asked questions

Is anxiety after a car accident a minor injury?

It may be treated as part of a minor injury. If anxiety is documented only as a reaction to a soft-tissue injury, the insurer may treat it as a clinically associated sequela and keep you in the MIG. A diagnosed, accident-related psychological impairment, supported by medical evidence, can fall outside the definition.

Can I be removed from the MIG months after the accident?

Yes, if new medical evidence supports it. A later psychological diagnosis can be submitted to the insurer to request reconsideration of the MIG classification, including through an OCF-18 when assessment or treatment is proposed.

Are my clinic’s MIG intake forms enough to prove a psychological injury?

Not on their own. The Guideline states that the health practitioner’s review of psycho-social risk factors “does not involve a formal psychological assessment.” A diagnosis from a qualified professional and medical records documenting your symptoms can be important evidence.

Do I have to attend the insurer’s psychological examination?

Generally, yes, if the examination is properly requested under section 44 and the notice meets the legal requirements. Missing a properly requested examination may prevent you from applying to the LAT, although the Tribunal may permit an application.

Sources: O. Reg. 34/10, Statutory Accident Benefits Schedule, sections 3(1) (“minor injury”, “impairment”, “health practitioner”), 15(1)(b), 18(1), 18(5), 38(3), 38(5) to 38(11), 38(13), 44(1), 44(3), 44(5), 44(6), 44(9), 55, 56 (e-Laws, consolidation period from July 1, 2026); Insurance Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. I.8, section 280; Superintendent’s Guideline No. 01/14, Minor Injury Guideline, sections 1, 2(g), 4, 7(b) and 8(d); Torgbor v. TD General Insurance Company, 2026 CanLII 56654 (ON LAT), June 5, 2026.

VIA Legal Services Professional Corporation. Naira Velumyan is a Licensed Paralegal in Ontario (LSO #P21370). This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice for your specific situation.

Naira Velumyan

Naira Velumyan is a Licensed Paralegal in Ontario and the founder of VIA Legal. She holds a PhD in Psychology, which shapes how she handles psychological injury claims. Read more about Naira

Placed in the MIG?

We offer a free case review of your situation.

We use your details only to reply to you. Your information stays confidential. Privacy policy

Google reviews