VIA Legal (647) 460-3430 Free Case ReviewFree Case Review
Denied benefits About Naira Guides FAQ

Classified under the Minor Injury Guideline in Ontario: how to challenge it at the LAT

If your insurer has classified your injuries under the Minor Injury Guideline (MIG) and denied a Treatment and Assessment Plan (OCF-18), you may be able to challenge that decision at the Licence Appeal Tribunal (LAT).

Start by reviewing the insurer's denial letter to see whether it provides medical reasons for the decision. Gather medical records and reports supporting your position that your injuries fall outside the MIG. You generally have two years from receiving the insurer's denial to file a LAT application. The application fee is $106. A case conference is held first, followed by a hearing if there is no settlement.

The MIG (Superintendent's Guideline No. 01/14) applies when a person's impairment is predominantly a minor injury, such as a sprain, strain or whiplash (SABS, s. 3(1)). Medical and rehabilitation benefits are generally limited to $3,500 plus applicable HST (s. 18(1)). For more information, read our Minor Injury Guideline guide.

What must the insurer's MIG notice say?

Under section 38 of the Statutory Accident Benefits Schedule (SABS, O. Reg. 34/10), an insurer must follow specific rules when responding to a Treatment and Assessment Plan (OCF-18):

  • Within 10 business days of receiving the OCF-18, the insurer must notify you which treatments and assessments they agree to pay for, which they refuse, and the medical and other reasons for their decision (s. 38(8)).
  • If the insurer believes the MIG applies, the notice must clearly state this (s. 38(9)).
  • If the insurer requires an examination under section 44, the notice may inform you of this requirement (s. 38(10)). Within 10 business days of receiving the examination report, the insurer must provide you with a copy (s. 38(13)) and “provide medical and any other reasons” if they determine that the MIG applies (s. 38(14)).

Under s. 38(11), if the insurer fails to provide a notice that complies with s. 38(8), they cannot take the position that the MIG applies. They must also pay for the goods and services described in the OCF-18, from the 11th business day after receiving the plan until a proper notice is given.

Why is MIG classification important in LAT disputes?

Section 38(5) allows an insurer to refuse an OCF-18 for treatment during a period when the MIG applies, and under s. 38(6) that refusal “is final and is not subject to review.” A LAT dispute over such a denial therefore generally turns on whether your impairment is predominantly a minor injury.

In Zapanta v. Security National Insurance Company (LAT, April 24, 2026), the claimant was seen only by paramedics after the accident and did not go to hospital (para 5). The Tribunal found insufficient medical evidence that she sustained a concussion in the January 2023 accident (para 17), upheld the denial under s. 38(5) and (6) (paras 22, 23, 26), and granted no award.

Removal from the MIG is the first step. In Gavey v. Wawanesa Insurance, 2024 CanLII 77430 (ON LAT), the Tribunal preferred the early concussion diagnoses (para 27), yet the disputed physiotherapy plan was not approved (paras 29 to 36). Outside the MIG, the question for each plan is whether its goods and services are reasonable and necessary (s. 38(3)(c), (8)).

How long do you have to apply to the LAT?

Under SABS s. 56, an application “shall be commenced within two years after the insurer's refusal to pay the amount claimed.” The LAT's guidance says to file “within two years after receiving this notice from the insurance company.” Section 56 contains no provision for pausing the two-year period while you ask the insurer to reconsider.

Section 7 of the Licence Appeal Tribunal Act, 1999 allows the Tribunal to extend the time “either before or after the expiration”, if satisfied “that there are reasonable grounds for applying for the extension and for granting relief.” The LAT warns that a late application may be refused. See also late Accident Benefits claims.

Under SABS s. 55(1)2, you cannot apply to the LAT if the insurer properly required a section 44 examination and you have not complied, unless the Tribunal permits it (s. 55(2)). See insurer examinations.

Who has to prove what in a MIG dispute?

In Dawkins v. BelairDirect Insurance Company, 2024 CanLII 81222 (ON LAT), the Tribunal wrote: “Concussions and post-concussive syndrome, if established, fall outside the MIG” (para 23). The SABS sections above do not state who bears the burden of proof in a MIG dispute, so a person disputing the classification should be prepared to provide medical evidence of an accident-related injury.

What medical evidence has the Tribunal weighed?

  • A diagnosis close to the accident. In Gavey, the claimant went to urgent care the day after the accident with headaches and light sensitivity (para 12), and on the third day was diagnosed with a likely concussion (para 13). Her family doctor recorded the concussion later (paras 14, 16). The Tribunal preferred these diagnoses to the opinion of the insurer's section 44 physician eight months later (paras 18, 27) and found that a family physician can diagnose a concussion and that a neurologist's opinion is not required (para 24).
  • The right professional. In Dawkins, a chiropractor recorded a “possible concussion” (para 24), and the Tribunal found his diagnoses were outside his scope of practice (paras 13, 26). The CT scan on the day of the accident was normal, and a later “concussion” entry had no clear basis (paras 25 to 26). The claimant remained in the MIG.
  • Psychological symptoms documented over time. In Torgbor v. TD General Insurance Company, 2026 CanLII 56654 (ON LAT), the claimant was removed from the MIG based on a psychologist's diagnosis and walk-in clinic records documenting low mood and later anxiety and insomnia (paras 22 to 30). The insurer's psychologist received less weight, partly because one test he used was designed for native English speakers (para 27).
  • Imaging. In Marcelo v. The Personal Insurance Company, 2026 ONSC 974, a CT scan on the day of the accident showed a contusion (para 4). The LAT kept the claimant in the MIG because her impairment was not above minor (paras 6 to 7). The Divisional Court held that the definition is injury-based (paras 30 to 31) and removed her from the MIG without returning the question to the Tribunal (paras 43 to 44).

See also concussion evidence and the MIG.

How does a LAT dispute proceed?

  1. Application. You complete the Application by an Injured Person, list the documents you intend to rely on, serve the insurer and file the application with a Certificate of Service, by e-File or mail. The LAT does not process applications sent by email. The $106.00 fee is non-refundable once the LAT confirms the claim can go ahead.
  2. Response. The insurer responds within 14 days of being served, unless the Tribunal specifies another period (LAT Rule 20.2).
  3. Case conference. Each party files and serves a case conference summary at least 10 days before the conference (Rule 20.4). It is a confidential two-hour meeting led by an adjudicator, usually by telephone, and both parties must attend. The LAT says it usually takes place 3 to 5 months after a completed application.
  4. Hearing. In writing, by videoconference or, in limited circumstances, in person, before a different adjudicator. The LAT says it typically takes place 4 to 8 months after the case conference, with a decision typically issued 60 to 120 days after the hearing.
  5. After the decision. Reconsideration may be requested within 21 days of the decision (Rule 18.1). An appeal to the Divisional Court may be made on a question of law only (Licence Appeal Tribunal Act, 1999, s. 11(6)), within 30 days according to the LAT.

Can you get an award, interest or costs?

If the Tribunal finds that an insurer “unreasonably withheld or delayed payments”, Reg. 664 s. 10 allows a lump sum of up to 50 per cent of the amount the person was entitled to at the time of the award, together with interest on all amounts then owing at 2 per cent per month, compounded monthly. It is discretionary: no award was granted in Torgbor or Zapanta. Interest on disputed benefits, at the prejudgment interest rate, runs from the date the application is brought until a settlement is reached or a decision is issued that finally disposes of the dispute (SABS s. 51(4)). Costs may be awarded for unreasonable, frivolous, vexatious or bad faith conduct and are capped at $1,000 per full day of attendance (Rules 19.1 and 19.6).

Who can represent you at the LAT?

Under LSO By-Law 4, s. 6, a licensed paralegal can represent a party before an Ontario tribunal, including the LAT, in Accident Benefits claims, excluding a claim of a person who “has or appears to have a catastrophic impairment”. VIA Legal represents clients in Accident Benefits claims, including those under the Minor Injury Guideline (MIG); for cases involving potential catastrophic impairment (CAT), we collaborate with experienced personal injury lawyers. See Paralegal or lawyer after a car accident.

What should you do if the insurer kept you in the MIG?

  1. Find the insurer's notice, note the date you received it, and check that it gives medical and other reasons (s. 38(8), (9), (14)).
  2. Mark the two-year deadline following the insurer's refusal (s. 56).
  3. Attend any properly required section 44 examination and request the report if you have not received it (s. 38(13)).
  4. Collect your medical records and ask your physician to record the diagnosis, the symptoms, when they began and whether they are related to the accident.
  5. Submit the new medical evidence to the insurer and request reconsideration. The two-year limit keeps running.
  6. If the insurer does not change their position, file an application with the LAT and serve it on the insurer.

Frequently asked questions

Can the LAT review an OCF-18 denied because of the MIG?

Not directly. A refusal under s. 38(5) is final under s. 38(6), so the dispute generally turns on whether the MIG applies.

What if two years have passed since the denial?

An extension may be possible under s. 7 of the Licence Appeal Tribunal Act, 1999, if the Tribunal finds reasonable grounds. It is discretionary, and a late application may be refused.

Does the insurer pay extra if they were wrong?

Not automatically. An award under Reg. 664 requires a finding that the insurer unreasonably withheld or delayed payments. Interest on disputed benefits is governed by SABS s. 51.

Can a paralegal represent me in a MIG dispute?

Yes. A licensed paralegal can represent you at the LAT in Accident Benefits disputes, except claims involving a person who has or appears to have a catastrophic impairment.

Free review of your denial. Send us the insurer's letter and the date you received it. We review it for free and explain whether a LAT application makes sense for you. We speak English, Russian, Ukrainian and Armenian.

Sources: O. Reg. 34/10 (SABS), ss. 3(1), 18(1), 38, 51(4), 55, 56; R.R.O. 1990, Reg. 664, s. 10; Licence Appeal Tribunal Act, 1999, ss. 7, 11(6); LAT-AABS, Application and hearing process; LAT-AABS, Forms, filing and fees; Licence Appeal Tribunal Rules, Rules 18.1, 19, 20.2, 20.4; LSO By-Law 4, s. 6; Superintendent's Minor Injury Guideline 01/14; Marcelo v. The Personal Insurance Company, 2026 ONSC 974 (Div. Ct.); Torgbor v. TD General Insurance Company, 2026 CanLII 56654 (ON LAT); Dawkins v. BelairDirect Insurance Company, 2024 CanLII 81222 (ON LAT); Gavey v. Wawanesa Insurance, 2024 CanLII 77430 (ON LAT); Zapanta v. Security National Insurance Company (ON LAT, April 24, 2026).

VIA Legal Services Professional Corporation. Naira Velumyan, Licensed Paralegal (LSO #P21370). General information, not legal advice for your situation.

Naira Velumyan

Naira Velumyan is a Licensed Paralegal in Ontario and the founder of VIA Legal. She holds a PhD in Psychology, which shapes how she handles psychological injury claims. Read more about Naira

Placed in the MIG?

We offer a free case review of your situation.

We use your details only to reply to you. Your information stays confidential. Privacy policy

Google reviews