Pre-existing conditions and the Minor Injury Guideline in Ontario: the section 18(2) exception
If, before this accident, you had a back or neck problem, arthritis or an injury from an earlier accident, and the insurer has placed you in the Minor Injury Guideline (MIG), section 18(2) of the SABS may provide an exception to the $3,500 limit.
This exception applies only if your health practitioner determines and provides compelling evidence that a pre-existing medical condition, documented by a health practitioner before the accident, will prevent you from achieving maximal recovery from the minor injury caused by this accident if you remain subject to the MIG’s limits.
The Guideline states that it is intended and expected that the vast majority of pre-existing conditions will not exclude a person from the MIG.
For the basics, see our guide to the Minor Injury Guideline in Ontario and what the $3,500 limit pays for.
What does section 18(2) of the SABS say?
Section 18(1) of the Statutory Accident Benefits Schedule (SABS, O. Reg. 34/10) limits medical and rehabilitation benefits to $3,500 when the impairment is predominantly a minor injury, plus any applicable HST for accidents on or after June 3, 2019. Section 18(2) creates the exception:
“Despite subsection (1), the limit in that subsection does not apply to an insured person if his or her health practitioner determines and provides compelling evidence that the insured person has a pre-existing medical condition that was documented by a health practitioner before the accident and that will prevent the insured person from achieving maximal recovery from the minor injury if the insured person is subject to the limit or is limited to the goods and services authorized under the Minor Injury Guideline.”
The wording contains four requirements:
- Who: the insured person’s health practitioner. Under the SABS, this includes a physician, chiropractor, dentist, occupational therapist, optometrist, psychologist, physiotherapist, registered nurse with an extended certificate of registration or speech-language pathologist, subject to their legal authority to treat the particular impairment.
- What: a pre-existing medical condition.
- When: the condition was documented by a health practitioner before the accident.
- Its effect: the condition will prevent maximal recovery from the minor injury if the person is subject to the $3,500 limit or restricted to the goods and services authorized under the Guideline.
The exception applies where the impairment “is predominantly a minor injury” (Guideline 01/14, s. 4). It is a separate route from showing that the injury falls outside the definition of a minor injury, as may be the case with a concussion or a diagnosed psychological impairment.
If section 18(2) applies, the $3,500 limit no longer applies. The general medical and rehabilitation benefits limit under section 18(3) is $65,000 plus any applicable HST, unless modified by optional benefits.
Attendant care benefits are payable under section 14 only “if the impairment is not a minor injury”.
What does “compelling evidence” mean?
The SABS and the Guideline do not define the phrase. The Guideline sets out how the evidence is provided and emphasizes the high threshold:
- “Compelling evidence is to be provided using the Treatment and Assessment Plan (OCF-18) with attached medical documentation, if any, prepared by a health practitioner.”
- “The existence of any pre-existing condition will not automatically exclude a person’s impairment from this Guideline.”
- The exception applies “only in extremely limited instances”, where the evidence “satisfactorily demonstrates” the documented condition and its effect on recovery.
- Exclusion based on “reasons or evidence falling short of this requirement is inconsistent with the intent of the SABS and this Guideline”.
The evidence therefore has to address both parts of the test. Pre-accident medical records may establish that the condition existed before the accident, but do not, on their own, establish that it will prevent maximal recovery within the MIG.
Is a pre-existing condition enough to be removed from the MIG?
A medical history may include, for example, degenerative changes on an earlier X-ray, osteoarthritis, a previous whiplash injury or recurring low back pain. Section 18(2) asks a further question: whether that condition will prevent maximal recovery from the minor injury caused by this accident if treatment is limited to the MIG.
“Maximal recovery” is also left undefined in the SABS and the Guideline. Under the Guideline, a person who reaches maximal recovery during a treatment block is discharged. The treatment phase will not typically exceed 12 weeks after the initial visit and consists of three four-week blocks.
A practitioner’s explanation may be more useful when it addresses, for that person:
- the condition, when and by whom it was diagnosed, and its status just before the accident;
- how it interacts with the soft-tissue injury caused by this accident;
- why the treatment authorized under the MIG, within the $3,500 limit, will not allow maximal recovery;
- what treatment or assessment is proposed instead.
In the OCF-18, Part 7 asks whether, before the accident, the applicant had “any disease, condition or injury that could affect their response to treatment” and whether it was investigated or treated in the past year. Part 4 has a separate statement for the exception and asks the practitioner to provide an explanation and compelling evidence to support the recommendation.
Which medical records should you gather?
Because the condition must have been documented before the accident, records created after the accident cannot, on their own, satisfy that requirement. However, they may help explain how the pre-existing condition affects recovery. Useful records may include:
- Family physician clinical notes and records from the years in which the condition was diagnosed or treated.
- Specialist consultation reports, for example from a rheumatologist, orthopaedic surgeon or physiatrist.
- Imaging reports from before the accident (X-ray, CT, MRI).
- Physiotherapy or chiropractic records from before the accident, and records from a previous accident claim, such as earlier treatment plans and insurer examination reports.
- Medical records created before you moved to Canada, with a certified translation. The SABS defines a physician as “a person authorized by law to practise medicine” without expressly limiting this to Ontario; the weight of foreign records is a question of evidence.
Registered massage therapists and pharmacists are not included in the SABS definition of a health practitioner. Their records may provide useful context, but on their own may not satisfy the requirement that the pre-existing condition was “documented by a health practitioner”. It also helps to check that the clinic’s records of prior conditions are consistent with your family physician’s records.
Classified under the MIG with a condition you had before the accident?
Ask us for a free reviewHow is the OCF-18 submitted and how does the insurer respond?
The Guideline provides for an OCF-18 or a referral at two points: after the initial visit, where there is compelling evidence of a pre-existing condition (s. 7(c)(iii)), and at discharge, if intervention outside the Guideline is required (s. 8(e)(ii)).
Under section 38(3) of the SABS, the health practitioner must indicate in the OCF-18 that the person qualifies for an exception to the MIG because of a documented pre-existing medical condition, even though the accident-related injury is considered minor.
The insurer’s response is governed by section 38:
- Within 10 business days after receiving the plan, the insurer must give notice identifying what they agree and do not agree to pay for, including the medical reasons and all of the other reasons (s. 38(8)).
- If the insurer believes the MIG applies, the notice must say so (s. 38(9)). The insurer may require an insurer examination under section 44 (s. 38(10)).
- If the insurer fails to give the required notice, they are prohibited from taking the position that the MIG applies and must pay for the plan’s goods and services for the period set out in s. 38(11).
For clinics, the dates covered by the plan matter. Under section 38(5), the insurer may refuse to accept a plan covering a period during which the person is entitled to goods or services under the Guideline. Under section 38(6) that refusal “is final and is not subject to review”. Section 38(7) allows a person receiving MIG treatment to submit a plan for a different treatment period.
If the insurer maintains the MIG classification, new medical evidence can be submitted to request reconsideration. If the insurer does not change their position, the dispute can be brought before the Licence Appeal Tribunal. Under section 56, an application must generally be commenced within two years after the insurer’s refusal to pay the amount claimed. Under section 55, failure to comply with a properly requested insurer examination may prevent a person from applying to the Tribunal unless the Tribunal permits the application.
See what to do when Accident Benefits are denied and what an insurer examination means.
What should you do if you had a condition before the accident?
- Tell the clinic at the initial visit about the pre-existing condition, when it was diagnosed and who treated it.
- Request copies of your family physician’s records and imaging reports from before the accident.
- Ask your health practitioner whether the evidence supports the section 18(2) exception and, if it does, whether an OCF-18 with an explanation and the pre-accident records attached is appropriate.
- Read the OCF-23 and OCF-18 before signing and ask for copies. Keep the insurer’s written notice and note the date you received it.
- Comply with a properly requested examination, unless there is a valid reason not to.
- If the insurer maintains the MIG classification, submit new medical evidence to request reconsideration or consider a Tribunal application, keeping the two-year limitation period in mind.
Our team can review your pre-accident records and the insurer’s MIG decision with you. We work in English, Russian, Ukrainian and Armenian.
Frequently asked questions
Does arthritis remove me from the MIG?
Not on its own. The Guideline states that a pre-existing condition “will not automatically exclude” a person from the MIG. Your own health practitioner must provide compelling evidence that the arthritis, documented before the accident, will prevent maximal recovery from the minor injury caused by the accident within the MIG.
Do I need medical records from before the accident?
Yes. Section 18(2) requires a pre-existing medical condition “documented by a health practitioner before the accident”. Later records can explain the effect of the condition, but they cannot replace the required pre-accident documentation.
I was injured in an earlier car accident and still had symptoms. Does that count?
It may. Injuries from an earlier accident can be a pre-existing medical condition if they were documented by a health practitioner before this accident. The evidence must still explain why that condition will prevent maximal recovery from the new minor injury within the MIG.
Can section 18(2) be raised after MIG treatment has started?
Yes. You can request an exception under section 18(2) even after MIG treatment has started. Your health practitioner may submit an OCF-18 with supporting medical evidence. However, there are rules about when the treatment in the plan can take place. If the insurer refuses, you generally have two years from the refusal to apply to the Licence Appeal Tribunal.
Sources: O. Reg. 34/10, Statutory Accident Benefits Schedule, ss. 3(1) (“health practitioner”, “physician”, “minor injury”), 14, 18(1) to 18(4), 38(3), 38(5) to 38(11), 55, 56 (e-Laws, consolidation period from July 1, 2026, e-Laws currency date November 11, 2026); Superintendent’s Guideline No. 01/14, Minor Injury Guideline, ss. 4, 7(b)(i), 7(c)(iii), 8(a), 8(b), 8(e)(ii); FSRA, OCF-18 Treatment and Assessment Plan, AF-119E (2026), Parts 4 and 7.
VIA Legal Services Professional Corporation. Naira Velumyan is a Licensed Paralegal in Ontario (LSO #P21370). This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice for your specific situation.
